Will the EU now permit VAT deductions on the basis of non-compliant purchase invoices?

In a recent ruling the Court of Justice adopted the viewpoint that the tax authorities cannot refuse the right to deduct VAT just because certain required information was not stated on an invoice. In this particular case the authorities had all the information required to check whether all material conditions for exercising this right of deduction were met.

1. Principle: no compliant invoice - no deduction

Both EU law (the VAT Directive) and Belgian legislation assume that the VAT-payer must have a compliant purchase invoice in order to have the right to deduct VAT (and, of course, the VAT must also be related to an activity or transaction that entitles a deduction – we will not be further examining this point within the scope of this article). The notion of a ‘compliant purchase invoice’ must here be understood to be an invoice that contains all the required information as listed in the list of information that must appear on an invoice.

By virtue of this list it is required that, among other things, the invoice must state the scope and nature of the services provided, but with it not being specifically prescribed that the said services must be exhaustively detailed. It was exactly this sore point in the case that the European Court of Justice was presented with.

2. A vague description without a definite period stated on the invoice

A Portuguese VAT-payer acquired legal services from a legal firm. The legal firm had dispatched invoices with VAT for these services upon which was stated: ‘legal services in the period from … to the present’.

In her VAT return the VAT-payer had deducted the VAT charged in these invoices. But the Portuguese VAT authorities believed that this deduction was unjustified, as the invoices did not comply with the statutory requirements because the services performed were insufficiently detailed.

3. ....does still not suffice as invoice information!

The Court of Justice adhered to the reasoning of the Portuguese VAT authorities in the sense that the description on the invoices issued by the legal firm was inadequate because, on the basis of the description, the services provided cannot be determined to a sufficient extent. If ongoing services are involved, the invoice must clearly state the period to which the invoice pertains. Consequently, the invoice must contain both the start date and the end date of the period in which the services concerned were performed.

4. But this does not hinder the right to deduction!

After ruling that the invoices did not comply with the statutory requirements, the Court of Justice had an important addendum. If, notwithstanding a ‘formal defect’ on the invoice, it can be determined that the VAT is justifiably deducted, the VAT authorities may not refuse it. After all, the VAT authorities must take into account all the information on the invoices concerned as well as the supplementary documents and/or additional information submitted by the VAT-payer. The Court thus explicitly adopted the assertion that the right to deduction cannot be declined just because the invoice does not comply with all the formal requirements of information on an invoice.

The Court moreover found that the above reasoning did not prevent the imposition of a monetary fine or sanction, in the event of such formal breaches, proportionate to the gravity of the defect, for the purposes of penalising that non-compliance with the formal conditions.

5. What does this mean in concrete terms for Belgian invoices?

The fact that the Court of Justice ruled as it did is very good news for VAT-payers, certainly in a strictly formalised context in Belgium, but one must still treat the standpoint with care.

The ruling is not a free pass to stop checking whether received purchase invoices are complete and correct. On the one hand the Court of Justice sees no problem with (proportionally) penalising non-compliance with the formality requirements, which means that the Belgian VAT authorities can feel as if that point has been corroborated. On the other hand, in certain cases this standpoint can help us to temper the often stringent approach of the VAT authorities and to safely assert the right to deduction in situations where the invoice is not wholly compliant but where the actual circumstances or other documents completely substantiate that right to deduction.

What are the consequences and the opportunities?
Buying real estate in the Netherlands: are there tax benefits?
In recent years the purchase of property in the Netherlands has seen an uptick, especially in the beachside town of Cadzand, where 1,500 new apartments and houses are being be built between 2008 and 2020. This is the perfect opportunity to examine the (tax) consequences of buying real estate in the Netherlands and the opportunities it offers in respect of asset and inheritance planning. This artic
A reminder of the most significant tax-related points
‘For free’ is not always ‘VAT-free’
 ‘A free sample, a gadget with a corporate logo, rewarding faithful buyers and suppliers with a small gift…’ Every company is familiar with this situation, but are they also aware of the tax-consequences of these generous gestures? The tax authorities recently published a circular as a reminder of the most significant tax-related points for attention in this respect.  The rules&
A refresher on the current state of affairs
Interest on savings accounts with foreign institutions: Belgian rapped over the knuckles again for its exemption
With tax return season lurking on the horizon it is a good idea to have a refresher on the current state of affairs with respect to the exemption for interest on savings accounts. The general rule as regards the exemption At the present, the first bracket of €1,880 (for tax year 2018, base sum of €1,250) of the income from regulated savings accounts (those accounts where the bank complies
The regional benefits have diverged completely
Home-owner taxes in the tax year 2017
'Own homes' have been a regional authority matter, since 2014. Even then, it was predicted that this would result in serious fragmentation and complication of the fiscal benefits for own homes. 
Powerful weapon for combating against fraud
Prejudgement administrative attachment for VAT gets repackaged
One of the measures used in the battle against tax fraud involves the amendment of the extant regulations for prejudgement attachments that VAT officials can levy on moveable property when, during an inspection, they have established that there are matters that indicate major fraud (organised or not). An example would be when they encounter goods in a warehouse that have been part of a carousel sc
There are a number of (negative) consequences
What happens if a tax audit decides that your company is no longer ‘small’?
From a tax perspective there are a number of advantages to a company being considered ‘small’. In this article we will take a brief look at those advantages. However, there are also considerable consequences when, during a tax audit, a company is deemed to no longer be small, and these not only affect the company itself, but others too.   A small company under article 15 of the Compani
The published circular creates clarity
Are fundraising dinners VAT-liable? We clear up the exemption for charitable support
When a VAT-exempted society decides to host an event for the purpose of raising funds, such as a fundraising dinner, it was often uncertain as to whether the event was exempt from VAT. In the wake of a legislative amendment in 2016 a circular has now been released to clear up matters. Introduction The VAT Code contains an exemption for the delivery of goods and services provided by specified s
The struggle against fiscal fraud
FATCA: Prevention is better than reclamation
The US Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act (FATCA) has been in effect since 1 July 2014. The law is part of the war on tax fraud and is aimed at tackling international tax avoidance by American citizens through a new system of global automatic data exchange. What obligations have been introduced under FATCA? Under FATCA certain identification, reporting and/or content obligations are imposed f
Limited to federal & Flemish regulations
Target group reductions for social security: Are you still aboard?
As a result of the 6th state reformation, the Regions now have the authority to oversee personal target group reductions (doelgroepverminderingen) in respect of the employer’s contribution to social security. Flanders has opted to simplify the target group system, as a result of which a number of existing measures have been scrapped and new target group reductions have been devised for the young
Good news for separated parents with kids in college
Joint parenting for tax purposes: children of age also count
At the start of this year the authorities published a circular explaining the amendment to the article allowing joint parenting for tax purposes to now also be applied to children of age.

Subscribe to our newsletter